Somewhere Else – update Mar11

Ian HuIan Hu is Methodist minister at Somewhere Else – Liverpool City Centre Methodist Church. Ian tells how the 'bread church' has developed since being featured in expressions: the dvd – 1.

I was Superintendent Minister in the Liverpool South Circuit when Barbara Glasson, the founder of Somewhere Else, was moving on. I was in the third year of a five year post so was not able to be considered for the 'bread church' but, in the end, the community was unable – through the normal Methodist procedures – to secure a minister and the church got permission to advertise the post nationally.

When that happened, I could throw my hat into the ring. I did, went through the process, and eventually was asked if I would become the minister here.

I'm a long way from home in that I'm originally from San Francisco, California, but was recruited by the British Methodist Church to come to England. After serving as an Intern in the Preston Circuit, Lancashire, I was asked if I would take on a full post.

Following discussions with my family and church authorities, I made the move to Merseyside. Things have moved on quite a lot at Somewhere Else since it was first filmed for the DVD; I would say the main difference is in the community's overall maturity. The team of volunteers here have really gelled together and it's kind of a well-oiled machine. There was proof of that last summer when I took my sabbatical leave and, while we had ministers from all over the region coming in and assisting on bread-making days, it was really the core of volunteers who held everything together and kept it running – something they did so very, very admirably.

There is a really strong core team of volunteers and we hold regular training sessions on all kinds of areas, from food hygiene to troubleshooting in the bread-making process and group dynamics to health and safety. What is interesting to me is the make-up of the team; I would say that probably at least 75% of people who volunteer here are aged 25 and younger.

They come from all sorts of backgrounds. Some of them are Christians and there are lots of denominations represented; others have had exposure in their childhood to the church with some people coming into Somewhere Else who are at the very early stages of identifying and being able to talk about their faith and to really understand what makes them tick.

We continue to gather as a faith community around the making and sharing of bread. We have the bread-making every Tuesday and Thursday and it is very rare that we don't have at least one person who has never been here before. The session is open to the public and anyone and everyone is welcome to come up the stairs and join us. We've got single mums, single dads with kids during school holidays, job seekers, the homeless, all sorts of people.

Somewhere Else - leafletsWe also have retired people who come in and help and there are a lot of regular care groups. Care agencies helping people with learning or emotional difficulties bring their clients because there's a great opportunity for them to develop social skills and they really like what happens here.

Our worship time – for someone traditionally churched – does not resemble standard 'preaching from the front' church worship. It's scripturally based but is very much more in a discussion format; as a result we try to ensure that everyone feels safe within the worship space so they can express what they're feeling or how they're responding to the scripture.

This community sees it as important that people don't debate points within the worship. We are here to share and to feel safe rather than to argue a point home. This community likes to light candles when lifting up intercessions, joys, concerns and celebrations – it's just part of the personality here. Some people among us like to light a candle but prefer not to put their intercessions into words and that's perfectly fine too.

A large group of the regular bread makers will participate in worship though some people choose not to. They prefer to stay in the bread-making room and help those setting up for lunch at one o'clock.

A question that comes up quite often centres on whether we are an ecclesial community or another social agency? First and foremost I think this community places its priority on being a church. It would see the entire process of community building and faith sharing and story telling that happens around the bread making table to be an all encompassing Christian experience – including the sitting down for a communal meal together.

We make great efforts to ensure that those selling the Big Issue along Bold Street and a regular core of homeless persons and rough sleepers in the city are aware of us and know that they can come up at one o'clock and get a really warm welcome and a hot meal. We let them know that it's their choice to come up when they choose; some people we see quite regularly, others we will see occasionally and there are those who come in cycles. One thing's for sure, if they haven't been here for a while and they do come back they are instantly recognised and given what we like to term 'outrageous hospitality'.

Each Tuesday and Thursday sees a different community because we never know who's going to be here during the day and I would say probably one of the most exciting things about my post is being able to witness that and to see the dynamic as to how that plays out.

We do regard our communal lunch to be quite special because we have people sitting together around our table who wouldn't normally be together at all. We always have home made soup and fresh bread rolls made by us that morning. It's a wonderful, wonderful time. We also continue to meet on the third Sunday of the month to worship in fresh and creative ways.

As to what happens next within this community, we are actively looking ahead by taking the opportunity to look at where we have been and what challenges are in store for the future. One of the key issues is location. I would say that every square inch of space is utilised and there are times when we do get a large group visiting us and it can be quite a challenge to make sure that everyone's accommodated appropriately.

Somewhere Else - News from NowhereThere is a very, very synergistic relationship that was established from the beginning with the News from Nowhere bookshop which is the owner of this building. They are fabulous but basically the ministry and the mission of this place is evolving and we have to seriously consider what happens next. Another factor is our working closely with ecumenical partners – the Church of England and the United Reformed Church in particular. There are some very close ties now and this community is looking at how those ties can help us to strengthen the Christian witness in Liverpool city centre.

It's exciting for me as the minister that the entire community is taking that on board because it just feels like we're listening to the Spirit and intently praying for guidance.

I'm here for a five year post but at the end of my fourth year the community and I will talk about whether or not that post would be renewed – that's the normal process in the Methodist church. There's no doubt that it is a challenge and it's an entirely different dynamic working in the city centre but it is great and I feel like I've quickly become part of the furniture around here.

We get a lot of visitors from all over the country. They have read about Somewhere Else – in Barbara Glasson's books and elsewhere – seen the Fresh Expressions DVD or heard about us through word of mouth. We also do a lot of training and we have had placements here for people training for ministry in the United Reformed Church, the Methodist Church and the Church of England.

We are aware of several other communities who like to use the 'bread church type of ethos' – there's one in Ellesmere Port and another in the city centre of Chester. They're both doing quite well so it's good to know that Somewhere Else is inspiring similar initiatives along the way.

Immanuel Church

Graylingwell Chapel, in the centre of an 85-acre former hospital site in Sussex, had been derelict for years when Steve and Sarah Flashman first saw it. Now – as home to Immanuel Church – it's on course to be the spiritual heart of a landmark eco-friendly housing development. Ministers Steve and Sarah discuss the turnaround in fortune.

Immanuel Church - homes

Immanuel Church was actually born fifteen years ago, long before we were on the scene, when a group of people in Chichester started meeting in someone's home. The church soon grew and people felt that God was calling them to work in partnership with St Paul's Church in the Winterbourne Road area of the city. Meeting at St Michael's Hall, the church outgrew the facilities there and after a long period of consultation and negotiation moved into Graylingwell Chapel. The idea was to create a vibrant new community base open to all.

Immanuel Church at Graylingwell Chapel is not a Parish Church. We are in the parish of St Paul's, Chichester but we are becoming a Bishop's Mission Order and have been given a special brief as a 'network church' and 'missional community' to live out our Christian faith in ways that connect with people in this area. This means we can develop new forms of church whilst respecting Anglican traditions.

Immanuel Church - chapelSeven hundred homes will be built on this site over the next seven years. Graylingwell Chapel had been disused for eleven years by the time we first saw it; previously this late Victorian building had only been used by staff and patients of the NHS hospital here.

We came to Immanuel Church as ministers four years ago to live on the Winterbourne estate which is a mix of social housing and student lets. We chose to live on the estate because we felt it was really important for us to be incarnational and live with the people we serve, our home is right by what is currently a fence surrounding the Graylingwell site. It is possible to see the Chapel from where we live – though it was a bit difficult to do that initially.

When we first drove up to Graylingwell, the whole area was a mess and you couldn't really access the chapel building at all but we managed to make our way through the foliage to get to it and we could see the vision even then.

Immanuel Church - treesAs a result we started to establish a relationship with the developers, Linden Homes, and also got in touch with the architects and the site's owner English Partnerships (which became part of the Homes and Communities Agency in December 2008). A public consultation was held before moving forward with the development and some 200 people came to the site's old theatre building.

Plans were outlined for what will be the UK's largest carbon neutral development. All the homes are planned as energy efficient with heating supplied by a central heating and power plant as part of an on-site energy centre. The idea is that it would be a benchmark for future sustainable developments across the country.

The architects put up big sheets of paper and they asked us all to write our own dreams and visions for this site. We wrote that our dream was that Graylingwell Chapel would become the community's spiritual heart.

Later, during the consultation, the development team stood up in front of this packed crowd and said that when first researching their design ideas, they came to Chichester and could see the centre of the city was in the shape of a cross with roads from north, south, east and west meeting at the Market Cross near the cathedral. They had then drawn a line through the centre of a map showing the Graylingwell site and discovered – from aerial photos – that the Chapel building was at the centre of it all. They then said they hoped it would become the spiritual heart of Graylingwell and they drew a heart around the Chapel on their PowerPoint map.

Immanuel Church - heartWe were astounded that they used the same phrase as we had written down a little while earlier! The image of the heart has since become the church's logo.

The developers and architects also emphasised that they wanted to connect Graylingwell with Winterbourne, saying the communities needed to be interwoven. To illustrate this they drew a line to show where the cycle paths were scheduled to run – one was a direct route through what had been an old orchard from our front door directly to the chapel door. We took it as such an encouragement that this was definitely where God had called us and wanted us to be.

It helped us in developing relationship with all of these key people that we could point to the community work we were already involved in. Our Winterbourne Wonderland event on the streets of the estate involves games for the children, refreshments, food, a live band and a specially built grotto for Father Christmas.

And in the middle of the summer, we bring the seaside to Winterbourne Road with our Summersdale Seaside Special. We bring in sand, a huge Hawaiian backdrop and 'beachside' cocktails. Apart from the street parties, we also run a fellowship group in an elderly care home; have a social outreach clear-up group, and lots of other things.

There is no focus to the community around here. We only have one shop on the estate and it's the place where people meet – and kids loiter outside. At the time of building relationship we knew we couldn't develop a geographic focus but we could create a focus for something good. It was, and still is, important that the community feel they can 'own' what we do. Thankfully there has certainly been proof of that along the way.

Immanuel Church - inside the chapelWhen we moved in to the chapel building in Easter 2010, all the church turned up to clean the place and we came across a lady we didn't know doing the hoovering! It turned out that the church had helped her to clear and tidy up her garden and she wanted to give something in return.

We also have a New Community Rock Choir. Fifty eight people signed up for it and only a handful has any link at all with church but this is most definitely 'their' chapel.

The fact is that since moving in here we've had one miracle after another. Linden Homes put in a temporary electricity supply but didn't have permanent lighting. Then a member of our church was driving along when he saw lights being put into a skip. It turned out a school was being refurbished. He asked if he could have them for the church and he drove off again with all the lighting we needed.

A couple of weeks before we were due to move in, it was suggested that we might have to pay £10,000 a year to use the place! Some of our people were not at all sure about continuing with the whole thing but we said, 'This is the vision that God has given us and we will still move in on Easter weekend. If He wants us here, he will provide what we need.' The Monday before moving day one of the directors of the development company contacted us to say, 'We have decided we are not going to charge that figure. For the next two years you can use it for £1 a year.'

Immanuel Church - artWe are developing relationship as well as developing trust both with the community and those involved in delivering this scheme. We were able to put together quite detailed business plans for what was then English Partnerships and this really helped them to recognise that we were serious about the whole thing.

The idea of denominations or different streams of church is completely incomprehensible to many. If you mention to a lot of people in this area that we are from the Church of England, many wouldn't really know – or care – what that means. If people do have a view of what Christians were like, it would tend to be a stereotypical one of 'wet fish handshakes' and blue anoraks. There is no expectation of anything different.

It was at the Bishop of Chichester's invitation that we started on the route of becoming a Bishop's Mission Order. There had been difficult times before Immanuel Church was formed, its beginning was born out of pain, but Immanuel wasn't formed as an alternative to another congregation. Its growth was very organic and developed naturally. It had also always remained within the CofE's Canon law so the BMO offered an opportunity to embark on a new stage of Immanuel's journey.

Immanuel Church, in all but its direct governance, is sympathetic to the CofE and the BMO acknowledges that some churches are seeking a form of official recognition that falls into the Order's bracket. It’s all about restoration, reconciliation and healing.

Immanuel Church - busWe are very missional with Graylingwell and since we have moved here, the culture of the church has significantly changed. About 120 adults are now part of the church with attendances of roughly 100 on Sunday, plus children. We're now praying for new growth from people coming in as converts and there are good signs for future relationship building. Linden Homes has set up a Community Development Trust and a community development worker is using the Chapel for parties for new residents. Our youth and children's work currently takes place in a double decker bus parked alongside the Chapel. We bought it on eBay and later this year we do hope to go on the road with it.

The building itself will be restored by Linden Homes at an estimated cost of £300,000. They will start to do that when 150 houses have been built – 70 have gone up so far. We will remain in the Chapel while works continue, all of which will be in line with the carbon neutral development around it.

In thinking about the fresh expressions way of being incarnational in a setting rather than being attractional and bringing people back into a church building, it's all about knowing your context. For us here we recognise that one of the things that draws people in is the Chapel itself because they are curious to see what it's like. You can't always work to a formula of getting out and staying out. Many are coming to the church because of its community arts emphasis. You have got to know your own community and recognise where people are at as well as having a real Spirit-inspired vision.

Immanuel Church - chapelGraylingwell Chapel is the new community venue in Chichester but we can see a time, as the site develops, when additional communities could well become those little churches that are very typical of fresh expressions. This might be seen as 'Chapel Central' to a network of churches.

We still find it amazing that it was the secular community of architects and developers that set Graylingwell Chapel's agenda as the spiritual heart. They want to create something that is very contemporary, very alive. In turn, people have picked up on the welcome, the friendship, the atmosphere of the place. It is easy to become concerned that they will be put off by liturgy, the way we worship, what we say in a sermon or whatever but we shouldn't assume that these things are barriers. Instead, friends and friendship are often the keys to them coming in the first place and then coming back for more. We have got to live community and give people a glimpse as to what that means – that's the heart of the Trinity after all isn't it?

Immanuel Church - art