Messy Church at St Pancras

Ruth Burrows tells how Messy Church continues to transform the ministry of St Pancras, Chichester.

It is amazing to see what God has done at St Pancras since we first launched Messy Church in November 2011. Before then we were really struggling to connect with young families in the area, in fact we would have no children at all in our congregation. Our Messy Church now attracts about 50 adults and 40 children and it has gone up beyond this on occasions!

I lead a team which is involved in prayer, planning and preparation for each of the Messy Church sessions at St Pancras. Students from the University of Chichester also lend a helping hand at our Messy Church, which runs on the first Sunday of the month from 4pm to 5.30pm.

Messy Church St Pancras - handsIt's partly bridge-building, some parents have started to bring their children along to St Pancras services, but I'd say a lot of people think of Messy Church as their church because there is worship, there is biblical input and there is relationship with God and each other.

The story really started in summer 2011, a few months after our Rector, Mark Payne, came to St Pancras. There was a Messy Church presentation going on at another church and Mark suggested that it would be good for someone to go along, find out about it and report back. Of course, he already knew about Messy Church… but he sent me along anyway as I have a nursery school and teaching background. He knew that I would be very enthused and encouraged about the whole thing! He also knew that I'd come back and say it was something we should do.

His response was, 'Great! So, when can we get started then?'

From there, our launch team came together and it was initially made up of people at the core of our church, those in leadership roles and with experience of children. It was quite a small team but, even at that time, it included a couple of students from the University of Chichester. When we got Messy Church off the ground in November 2011, we attracted maybe 10-15 adults and about 10 children.

Messy Church St Pancras - craftSince then, the team has changed and we have had increasing support from students – many of whom have become integrated in the wider life of the church as a result. This has been fantastic to see but right from the start it was emphasised that we didn't want to have a very forthright evangelical approach to outreach through Messy Church. I think some people felt that if you don't 'hit' people hard with the gospel message, then Messy Church is not worth doing. Well, we don't hit people hard with the message; I feel quite passionately about that. However, we do feel that Messy Church is offering an opportunity for many people to discover God's love – maybe for the first time. Messy Church is right for us in our context because it is non-pressurising and really gentle, with much being conveyed through conversations and relationships.

Right from the start we looked on Messy Church as 'church' and, soon after we started, quite a number of those involved took part in a training session with Lucy Moore. This helped to reinforce the ideas that we had been expressing as a team about Messy Church's purpose.

I now lead a team of about 15, eight of whom are students. We also have a couple of people from other churches from various denominations in the mix and that helps to bring different people in; it also saves it from being a St Pancras, Church of England, 'thing'. Also involved is a woman who runs the toddler group in the parish, a couple of like- minded teachers, the university students, and Mark (the Rector) and curate, Chris Styles.

Messy Church St Pancras - Christingle orangeWe meet once a month, a week after we have had a Messy Church so that we can review what happened and learn from things that have gone well or not so well. I normally brainstorm ideas and discuss these with the group but, as time has gone on, what has grown is a confidence from others in coming up with ideas. At first I was doing it all but now it is shared out a lot more. We plan what the next few themes are going to be and talk about particular families that have come to the fore in the last Messy Church session (perhaps through a personal conversation one of us has had) and how we can take these people forward in their next step of faith and discipleship. Our conversations revolve around building on the Bible stories that people have heard and highlight themes such as forgiveness and the person of Jesus.

So we might look at, 'What kind of things are we going to be talking about in the next Messy Church? What can come from this? What sort of conversations might this theme produce?' It's all about thinking ahead and trying to discern how God wants this to develop and what we need to do to join in with Him on it.

It is wonderful for those of us who have been on the team since day one to witness what God has done. Then we had no children, now we average about 40 children and 50 adults. Our 'problem' is now a very good one to have because we are reaching capacity so our question is, 'How are we to arrange things in future?'

Messy Church St Pancras - starsWe've found it an advantage for Messy Church to take place in our church building because it helps to take away any preconceived ideas about what Christians, and particularly clergy, may be like – but space is now at a premium. However, St Pancras also owns the building next door and our long-term plan is to use that so Messy Church can 'float' between the two sites. At this stage, the people who I have been more personally involved with at Messy Church are de-churched rather than unchurched but we are still at an early stage in the development of this fresh expression.

The good thing is that we don’t have any pressure to get the people who come along into 'normal' church. It's true that, before Messy Church, the average number of children in a service had been zero and now we might have between 5 and 10; that's not the intention of Messy Church but it's certainly been a bi-product! We’ve also had a couple of baptisms come from it, a mother and her children.

Another woman and her two children came for a while, started to come to services at St Pancras, did an Alpha course and then disappeared. She came back for a Messy Church barbecue to tell us she'd done Christianity Explored at a local Baptist Church and had stayed there. She was a bit embarrassed about going somewhere else but we said, 'That's fantastic. It's not about making you come to our church, it's just exciting that you have found this relationship with God'.

Messy Church St Pancras - houseA big challenge is to ensure that we don't get so bogged down in Messy Church's activities that we miss out on the opportunities to create meaningful relationships with those who come along. However, one of our strengths is that Mark or Chris is always free for a chat at Messy Church and that's really important. Normally both of them are there and it's great to have someone who isn't tied in to all that's going on with the art and crafts. It means that the mums and dads and carers don't have to be 'doing' something all the time; instead they'll have someone to have conversations with – and not in a pressurised way. It's also useful for many people to talk to clergy very informally!

I think the next step for us as a team is to explore further how people might start, or continue, their journey with Christ. This is so, so important because it's possible to be very heavily involved in something like Messy Church and yet not feel challenged by it.

As part of this review of the next phase of Messy Church @ St Pancras, I believe we also have to think about everything we do in our 'normal' church services. It's not just a case of asking the difficult questions of our Messy Church, we have to be prepared to do the same thing across the board. To me, that means when we pray, have 'a time of worship' and listen to a sermon or talk, we have to ask, 'What language are we using and what concepts are we drawing on?' We may go on and on about 'blessings' and 'outpouring' but for someone unfamiliar to church life, do they understand what we mean?

Messy Church St Pancras - cakeMessy Church has made me think so much about the people we wouldn't normally reach through traditional church, and those who have been hurt by church in the past. If our language and ways of doing things are a stumbling block to those people, we really need to think again.

msm North East – North Shields

You are invited to share a learning journey in a supportive community to be equipped for a lifetime of good practice and learning in growing fresh expressions of church.

Your local course

The Linisfarne Regional Training Partnership, the dioceses of Durham and Newcastle and the Methodist (North East Region) Discipleship and Ministries Network are delighted to make msm available locally. We believe it will be a significant resource for building the Kingdom of God in this area.

Individuals are most welcome, but we particularly hope that small groups from a church or fresh expression will come as this will deepen the impact of the course.

The course leaders and teachers include Elaine Lindridge, Tricia Mitchell, Roy Searle, Joanna Dobson, Stephen Lindridge, Jona Sewell, Sharon Pritchard, Rob Wylie, Tim Sanderson, Mark Bagnall, John Sinclair, Martin Ramsden and Michael Volland.

Course timetable and venue

Saturday 4th October 2014

Wednesday 8th October 2014

Wednesday 12th November 2014

Wednesday 3rd December 2014

Wednesday 14th January 2015

Saturday 31st January 2015

Wednesday 11th February 2015

Friday 6th to Sunday 8th March 2015

Wednesday 18th March 2015

Wednesday 22nd April 2015

Wednesday 13th May 2015

Wednesday 3rd June 2015

Saturday 20th June 2015

Saturdays are 10.00 to 16.00, weekdays 19.00 to 21.00, both at Church House, St John's Terrace, North Shields, NE29 6HS.

The residential is at Diocesan Youth Village, Pemberton Road, Allensford, DH8 9BA.

Cost

£300 per person, which covers all materials, refreshments and the weekend away.

Contact

Jenny Burton

Administrator

jennyburton@lindisfarnertp.org

0191 270 4144

Recommendations

This course sets the gospel of Jesus Christ right at the heart of everyday life. It nurtures and encourages, helps people to grow as mission-shaped disciples and equips them to make timeless truths relevant to our contemporary culture.

Rt Revd Frank White, Assistant Bishop of Newcastle

mission shaped ministry presents an excellent opportunity for the development of mission in this region. It will equip and inform individuals and teams as they respond to their call to make new disciples and embody the gospel in creative and innovative ways.

Dr Jocelyn Bryan, Postgraduate Director, St John's College, Cranmer Hall & Wesley Study

Centre Tutor

View mission shaped ministry in a larger map

Bearing fruit in fresh expressions

St Paul describes the gospel as 'bearing fruit and growing' (Colossians 1.6) and there is certainly little point in being involved in Christian ministry which does not bear fruit; however exciting it may seem.

For years the Fresh Expressions team has been reporting specific stories of fresh expressions of church but, with the notable exception of the Methodist national statistics, we have had limited, quantifiable reports of the scale and depth of what was being achieved. Now, courtesy of Canon Dr George Lings' research for the Church Commissioners, we have an in-depth study of nearly a quarter of all dioceses in the Church of England.

Released earlier this month, the study of these ten dioceses by Church Army's Research Unit reveals that fresh expressions account for 10% of total church attendance and 15% of church communities. Fresh expressions of church are mainly smaller and varied Christian communities. A key to further growth would seem to be the multiplication of the small. Get up to about 50 and, rather than get involved in all the complexities which come with size, plant again.

Here are some of the report's main findings.

Total attendance at fresh expressions in these ten dioceses is equivalent to planting an additional medium-sized diocese. In seven out of the ten dioceses, the numbers added equate to reversing the decline in those dioceses over 2006-2011 and in two other dioceses nearly does so. If this represents the work in ten dioceses what might be the scale for the whole Church of England?

These fresh expressions (at least 20 different recognizable models were noted) covered the full range of socio-economic settings in these dioceses and a wide spectrum of churchmanship. Appropriateness to local context is the key and different models connect better with different social groups. As the detailed report states, 'The great majority start from, and stay within, a parish'. Two fifths are network rather than neighbourhood based, addressing cultural groups unreached by existing work, but the attendance at network fresh expressions is 'mainly typical of the surrounding area'. The vast majority are all age, with 41% of attendance being under 16.

As reported by interviews with the leaders, 25% of those who attend are already members of a church, 35% are de-churched and 40% non-churched. The non-churched are the largest and fastest growing group within the population and the most significant mission field, so this is particularly encouraging. Planting teams are mainly small, most being between 3 and 12 people, showing that this is well within the reach of many more churches. On average, for every person sent as part of a team another 2.5 have been added. There is a low level of transfer growth, showing that these are not examples of 'more exciting church' for bored Christians! Encouragingly, 78% of these fresh expressions are taking intentional steps to encourage discipleship, not just attendance.

The other striking feature was the large number of lay leaders who had not had a previous formal role, or who had not previously been involved in leadership.

A large number of examples examined in these dioceses did not meet the criteria, and so have not been counted in the research results:

  • some were not missional; they were aimed at existing church people;
  • some were not ecclesial; there was no intention to plant a new congregation or church.

This was not a judgement about their value – just that they did not fit the criteria for a fresh expression of church. This confirms the need to maintain clear criteria and to continue to educate the Church about the nature of fresh expressions.

Many of these trends are also reflected in the Methodist 'Statistics for Mission' figures. In 2012, there were 46,000 people in 1,552 Methodist fresh expressions of church meeting monthly or more often – with nearly 8,000 lay volunteers supporting the work. In both denominations the greatest momentum in planting has been in the last few years. Fresh expressions are proving to be an effective means to church growth in the member churches.

These Church of England findings offer hope to all denominations and traditions engaged in this ministry. It is bearing fruit, most particularly in the many lives represented by these statistics. And for that reason, our historic denominations have every reason to give renewed priority to resourcing new forms of church, financially and in their deployment policies. There is still a long way to go.

+Graham Cray

‘Major impact’ of fresh expressions of church

Fresh expressions of church are having a major impact on growth in the Church of England – according to research released today (Thursday 16th January 2014).

Church of England statisticsThe detailed study, involving all fresh expressions of church in 10 dioceses, was carried out by the Church Army's Research Unit for the Church Commissioners. Canon Dr George Lings, the Unit's Director, said,

Nothing else in the Church of England has this level of missional impact and the effect of adding further ecclesial communities.

Between January 2012 and October 2013, researchers spoke to the leaders of 518 fresh expressions in the dioceses of Liverpool, Canterbury, Leicester, Derby, Chelmsford, Norwich, Ripon & Leeds, Blackburn, Bristol and Portsmouth. These dioceses were chosen to reflect variety in context, geographical spread and different stances towards fresh expressions.

The report comes as part of an 18-month research programme investigating factors related to church growth within the Church of England. Findings showed that, by 2012, four to five times as many fresh expressions were being started per year compared to 2004 -when the Mission-shaped Church report was launched.

The growth has been noticeably marked in the past three years. Some 44% of the fresh expressions in the research were launched between 2010 and 2012.

Evidence suggests that for every one person involved in the setting up of a fresh expression of church, there are now two and half more people. A typical fresh expression begins with 3-12 people and grows to 250% of that initial team size.

The findings were presented by George Lings at the Faith in Research Growth Conference in London today. The research in the 10 dioceses also headlines:

  • an estimated 24.5% of those attending fresh expressions of church are already members of a church, 35.2% are people who used to belong to church but who left for one reason or another while 40.3% are those with no previous church background at all.
  • the 13.5% of parishes in the dioceses surveyed had started a fresh expressions of church.
  • 52% of the fresh expressions of church are led by people who are not ordained, 40% are led by people who are not formally authorised. Two out of three lay leaders are women, two out of three ordained leaders are men; but the men are more likely to be paid and the women working voluntarily.
  • there are at least 20 different recognizable types of fresh expressions of church and the average size is 44.
  • fresh expressions of church can be found in all traditions in the Church of England. The fresh expressions of church meet in all kinds of venues at various times, days of the week and geographical settings. The world of fresh expressions of church is described as one of 'varied and smaller communities'.
  • 78% intentionally encourage discipleship, not just attract attenders. Over a third have communion services and a third have had baptisms. Half are taking some steps toward responsibility for their finances and two thirds for how they are led, very few have formal legal status within the Church of England.
  • the majority, 66%, either continue to grow numerically or maintain the growth gained. Of those surveyed, 25% did grow but are now shrinking while 9.7% have come to an end. Growth patterns vary according to a wide combination of factors, including the kind of fresh expression, social area served and frequency of meeting.

Bishop Graham Cray, Archbishops' Missioner and leader of the Fresh Expressions team, said,

This thorough research shows the numerical scale, the demographic spread and the sheer variety of fresh expressions of church in the Church of England. Particularly significant is the proportion of people involved who have never been part of any church in their lifetime, and the number of new lay leaders who have never previously been involved. These findings offer hope. and show that the Church of England does know how to draw unchurched people into Christian discipleship and fellowship, and that decline is not inevitable.

Dr Rachel Jordan, National Mission and Evangelism Adviser for the Church of England, added,

This research has shown the true impact of fresh expressions of church in the Church of England. There are far more fresh expressions than we had ever imagined, creatively reaching all types of people with the love and message of Jesus Christ – people who were previously entirely missing from our churches. It demonstrates that the Church of England can adapt and flourish in the present and promises that we have a real future.

Canon Phil Potter, Director of Pioneer Ministry, Diocese of Liverpool, and team leader elect of Fresh Expressions, commented,

This is the most in-depth research we've had to date and it offers an encouraging and exciting snapshot of how the Church is finding fresh confidence in evangelism through fresh expressions. There is much here to both inspire and challenge, and this research will help to release many more creative and strategic conversations as we work together for a new future.

You can download the full fresh expressions research report below or you can find the executive summary of the complete research, a video explaining the research and other resources on the Church Army website.